Set-back for Donation Tax Shelters

Over the last decade or so, thousands have reduced their tax bills by millions of dollars by purchasing prints, paintings, comic books, medical supplies and other items at one price and then donating the items to a charity at another, higher price. The CRA has aggressively attacked these donation arrangements to try to claw back the tax. Will it succeed? It might, if Canada (Attorney General) v. Nash, 2005 FCA 386, is any indication.

Finance on Income Trusts

In a press release that appeared on the Department of Finance website today, Finance Minister Ralph Goodale announced that Finance consultations on income trusts had ended and that it would attempt to solve the problem posed by the vehicles by reducing “personal income taxes on dividends, which will help level the playing field between corporations and income trusts.”

Limits on Fairness

Apparently, the Department of Finance and the CRA believe that you can have too much fairness in the tax system. In the 2004 budget, Finance introduced a ten-year limitation period for fairness applications. It appears that the CRA is now adopting a particularly strict interpretation of the rule to deny relief to taxpayers even where the events that form the basis for the fairness request occurred within the limitation period.